Another genealogical /
family history endeavor of Michael Ragsdale
Tracing Your Ancestry Through DNA
Popularized in recent years by its use in
high-profile criminal investigations and
paternity cases, DNA, deoxyribonucleic acid,
is most commonly used to prove a
relationship to an individual. New tests
created in recent years, however, have also
turned DNA into a popular tool for
determining ancestry. As DNA is passed down
from one generation to the next, some parts
remain almost unchanged, while other parts
change greatly. This creates an unbreakable
link between generations and it can be of
great help in reconstructing our family
histories.
While it
can't provide you with your entire family
tree or tell you who your ancestors are, DNA
testing can:
-
Determine
if two people are related
-
Determine
if two people descend from the same
ancestor
-
Find out
if you are related to others with the
same surname
-
Prove or
disprove your family tree research
-
Provide
clues about your ethnic origin
There are two
basic types of DNA tests available for
genealogical testing:
-
mtDNA
Tests - Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) is
contained in the cytoplasm of the cell,
rather than the nucleus. This type of
DNA is passed by a mother to both male
and female offspring without any mixing,
so your mtDNA is the same as your
mother's mtDNA, which is the same as her
mother's mtDNA. mtDNA changes very
slowly so it cannot determine close
relationships as well as it can
determine general relatedness. If two
people have an exact match in their
mtDNA, then there is a very good chance
they share a common maternal ancestor,
but it is hard to determine if this is a
recent ancestor or one who lived
hundreds of years ago. It is important
to keep in mind with this test that a
male's mtDNA comes only from his mother
and is not passed on to his offspring.
Example:
The DNA tests that identified the bodies of the
Romanovs, the Russian imperial family, utilized
mtDNA from a sample provided by Prince Philip, who
shares the same maternal line from Queen Victoria.
-
Y Line
Tests - More recently, the Y chromosome
in the nuclear DNA is being used to
establish family ties. The Y chromosomal
DNA test (usually referred to as Y DNA
or Y-Line DNA) is only available for
males, since the Y chromosome is only
passed down the male line from father to
son. Tiny chemical markers on the Y
chromosome create a distinctive pattern,
known as a haplotype, that distinguishes
one male lineage from another. Shared
markers can indicate relatedness between
two men, though not the exact degree of
the relationship. Y chromosome testing
is most often used by individuals with
the same last name to learn if they
share a common ancestor.
Example:
The DNA tests supporting the probability
that Thomas Jefferson fathered the last
child of Sally Hemmings were based on
Y-chromosome DNA samples from male
descendants of Thomas Jefferson's paternal
uncle, since there were no surviving male
descendants from Jefferson's marriage.
Markers on
both mtDNA and Y chromosome tests can also
be used to determine an individual's
haplogroup, a grouping of individuals with
the same genetic characteristics. This test
may provide you with interesting information
about the deep ancestral lineage of your
paternal and/or maternal lines.
What You Can
and Can't Learn From DNA Testing
Since
Y-chromosome DNA is found only within the
all-male patrilineal line and mtDNA only
provides matches to the all-female
matrilineal line, DNA testing is only
applicable to lines going back through two
of our eight great-grandparents - our
father's paternal grandfather and our
mother's maternal grandmother. If you want
to use DNA to determine ancestry through any
of your other six great-grandparents you
will need to convince an aunt, uncle, or
cousin who descends through an all-male or
all-female line to provide a DNA sample.
Additionally, since women don't carry the
Y-chromosome, their paternal male line can
only be traced through the DNA of a father
or brother.
DNA tests can
be used by genealogists to:
-
Link
specific individuals - e.g. test to see
whether you and a person you think may
be a cousin descend from a common
ancestor
-
Prove or
disprove the ancestry of people sharing
the same last name - e.g. test to see if
males carrying the CRISP surname are
related to each other
-
Map the
genetic orgins of large population
groups - e.g. test to see whether you
have European or African American
ancestry
What is your
goal?
To best use
DNA testing to learn about your ancestry you
should start by narrowing down a question
you are trying to answer and then select the
people to test based on the question. For
example, you may wish to know if the
Tennessee CRISP families are related to the
North Carolina CRISP families. To answer
this question with DNA testing, you would
then need to select several male CRISP
descendants from each of the lines and
compare the results of their DNA tests. A
match would prove that the two lines descend
from a common ancestor, though would not be
able to determine which ancestor. The common
ancestor could be their father, or it could
be a male from over a thousand years ago.
This common ancestor can be further narrowed
down by testing additional people and/or
additional markers.
Most Recent
Common Ancestor (MRCA)
When you
submit a DNA sample for testing an exact
match in the results between you and another
individual indicates that you share a common
ancestor somewhere back in your family tree.
This ancestor is referred to as your Most
Recent Common Ancestor or MRCA. The
results on their own will not be able to
indicate who this specific ancestor is, but
may be able to help you narrow it down to
within a few generations.
What can I
learn from my results?
An
individual's DNA test provides little
information on its own. It is not possible
to take these numbers, plug them into a
formula, and find out who your ancestors
are. The marker numbers provided in your DNA
test results only begin to take on
genealogical significance when you compare
your results with other people and
population studies. If you don't have a
group of potential relatives interested in
pursuing DNA testing with you, your only
real option is to input your DNA test
results into the many DNA databases starting
to spring up on the Net, in the hopes of
finding a match with someone who has already
been tested. Many DNA testing companies will
also let you know if your DNA markers are a
match with other results in their database,
provided that both you and the other
individual have given written permission to
release these results.
In
conclusion, it is vitally important to keep
in mind that DNA testing for the purposes of
proving ancestry is NOT a substitute for
traditional family history research.
Instead, it is a tool to be used in
conjunction with family history research to
aid in proving or disproving suspected
family relationships. It is definitely an
exciting new tool to add to your genealogy
toolbox!
Since markers on the
Y-chromosome are being analyzed in this
study, the DNA sample donor must be a
male with a direct male Ragsdale lineage.
Only males have the Y-chromosome and it is
passed directly, virtually unchanged, from
father to son, never to or from females.
Thus, females interested in obtaining
information about their Ragsdale lineage
would need to have a male relative (father,
brother, uncle, a male cousin, etc., from
their direct Ragsdale line) actually supply
the sample for analysis. Sample collection
is painless; it merely involves rubbing the
inside of the cheek with a foam swab (check
out this site for an overview of the sample
collection process).
Initially, one of the goals of the project
is to determine whether most Ragsdales are
derived from one common ancestor or whether
there were several initiating ancestors.
Other goals are to determine what lines are
derived from one Godfrey Ragsdale, the
patriarch of a well documented Ragsdale line
in the United States.
The primary company that is doing the DNA
analysis in this study is Family Tree DNA.
As a member of our Ragsdale surname group,
the cost for a 12 marker Y-chromosomal DNA
test by FTDNA is $99, for a 25 marker test
is $148, and for a 37 marker test is $189.
In addition, there is a $2 postage charge
for US residents and $4 for mailing the test
kits to foreign addresses. If you initially
obtain results for 12 or 25 markers, you can
(for a fee) upgrade to more markers at a
later date without sending a new test sample
since the company stores your original
sample for several years. It is strongly
recommended that participants in our DNA
project choose at least the 25 marker test,
however, if cost is a concern, you can
certainly feel free to just have the 12
marker test run initially (or contact me and
we will see about using the "general fund"
to help defray the associated cost).
Each participant is given a personal page on
the FTDNA web site where the participant's
test results, and comparisons of the results
with others in the FTDNA database, can be
viewed when the results become available
(typically 4 to 6 weeks after FTDNA receives
the test kits back in their facility). Most
communication with participants is by email
but FTDNA also eventually sends each
participant a written report and certificate
with that person's results. From time to
time a summary of the results obtained by
all members of the group will be posted at
this web site. Names of sample donors will
not be used in the web reports; the results
will be linked only to the earliest known
Ragsdale ancestors of each participant. In
this way the results become useful since it
is by comparing the results of each
participant with those of others that
meaningful genealogical conclusions can be
drawn.
Click Here for an
excellent site on DNA testing and genealogy
Click Here for a
Genetics Glossary
In this study 12, 25 or 37 markers (the 25
or 37 marker test is recommended) in the DNA
of the Y-chromosome of each sample are
examined. The Y-chromosome is unique in
human DNA in that it is only found in males
and is passed down from father to son
virtually unchanged. The term 'virtually' is
used because there is a small probability
(less than 1 %) that a mutation will occur
in the markers each generation. The net
result then is that the markers being
examined will have essentially the same (or
very similar) values for you, your father,
grandfather, great grandfather, etc., back
many generations (10 to 50 or more).
Obviously one cannot directly analyze such
DNA back more than 2 or 3 generations
because earlier ancestors have passed on.
However, the power of the technique is that
one does not have to analyze the DNA of
ancestors; one can obtain meaningful
genealogical information by comparing the
results from your DNA analysis with the
results from others. Consider, for example,
that your direct male ancestor of say 10
generations ago had 2 sons, one of whom you
are descended from, and the other who is the
ancestor of another group of Ragsdales. The
Y-chromosomal DNA from a living direct male
descendant of the second son should be
identical or very similar to your
Y-chromosomal DNA. The corollary of course
is that, if neither you nor the other
Ragsdale knew your lines back that far,
finding your DNAs to be so closely matched
would indicate that you have a common
ancestor. That could open up new avenues for
both of you to explore. Of course, if you
find that your Y-chromosomal DNA does not
match that of another Ragsdale one could
conclude that you are not closely related
(at least through the Ragsdale male line).
It
should be emphasized that the analyses for this
study can only be done on samples collected from
males since they are the only ones with the
Y-chromosome. Furthermore, because the
Y-chromosome is passed from father to son the
study can only find relationships that occur
through direct male lines. Since surnames
usually follow direct male lines, our study has
the potential to find many relationships among
various Ragsdales. Those of you who are females
with Ragsdale ancestors can still participate in
the study if you find a male relative (father,
brother, uncle, male cousin, etc.) who is
willing to supply a sample for analysis. By the
way, sample collection is painless; it involves
merely rubbing the inside of the cheek with a
foam brush collector.
One should point out that
there are several situations where the DNA
analysis might give an unexpected result. These
are sometimes referred to euphemistically as 'non-paternal'
events. Some
examples of such situations are: an unknown
adoption in your line, an illegitimate birth or
conception out of wedlock, some ancestor taking
the surname of a stepfather, etc. Of course, if
you have suspicions that one of these might have
occurred in your line, obtaining a DNA analysis
and comparing the results to those of presumed
relatives where it is unlikely such an event
happened could provide evidence whether such an
event has occurred in your line.
Many of us have been able to determine our
Ragsdale lines back to the 18th or 19th century
(4 to 8 generations or so) but have been stymied
in trying to trace our lines back further. Using
DNA analyses one has the potential to be able to
obtain information about earlier generations.
For example, suppose you have a well documented
Ragsdale line back to about 1810 in Tennessee
(my case exactly). You suspect that your
earliest known Ragsdale ancestor migrated to
Tennessee from either Virginia or North Carolina
but have not been able to make the connection.
You know that there are several known Ragsdale
lines in Virginia and North Carolina so it seems
a reasonable possibility. By having the DNA from
one of your Tennessee Ragsdales analyzed and
comparing the results to those obtained from the
various Virginia and North Carolina Ragsdale
lines, one would obtain evidence which one is
the most likely to be related to your line, and
thus you would know where to focus further
traditional genealogical research.
One of the general questions the Ragsdale
DNA study hopefully will be able to address
is whether virtually all Ragsdales come from
a common ancestor (say 500 to 1500 years
ago) or whether there were several different
initiating ancestors.
In
order to answer the question how many initiating
Ragsdale ancestors there were, one will need
broad participation by many Ragsdale lines. For
this reason alone, each of you with a Ragsdale
line is encouraged to participate in this study.
However, a potential added benefit from
participation is that some more immediate
questions may be resolved in your line and that
you may find totally unexpected relationships
with other Ragsdale lines.
If you have any questions concerning the
project that are not covered above do not
hesitate to contact either of the
coordinators.
|
|